Call Us Today!
Need Help Fast?
Not sure what your options are? Give us a call at (904) 396-5557 we would be more than happy to help you on this journey.
Preparing for custody mediation in Jacksonville? Call (904) 396-5557 for a free consultation with a Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator.
Florida courts processed 20,808 family mediation cases in FY 2024-25 as part of 102,106 total ADR cases statewide (FL Courts ADR) [1]. Mediation isn’t optional in Florida — F.S. § 61.183 requires it for all contested custody issues before you can get a trial date [2].
The stakes are high. Successfully mediated custody agreements typically cost $1,000-$8,000, while litigated custody battles run $15,000-$50,000+ (ABA) [3]. More importantly, mediated agreements tend to be more durable — parents who create their own agreement are more likely to follow it than those who have a judge impose one.
The 10 mistakes below are the most common reasons mediation fails. Avoiding them dramatically increases your chances of reaching a fair agreement.
The single biggest mistake is showing up to mediation without a written proposed parenting plan. Under F.S. § 61.13(2)(b), every Florida custody case requires a parenting plan that addresses time-sharing, parental responsibility, communication, holiday schedules, and dispute resolution [2].
If you don’t bring a specific proposal, you’re reacting instead of leading. Prepare:
Since July 1, 2023, Florida law presumes that equal time-sharing is in the child’s best interest (Ch. 2023-301) [4]. Walking into mediation demanding 80% or 90% of time-sharing without evidence to rebut the presumption is a non-starter.
The mediator and the other parent’s attorney know the law. If you want to deviate from 50/50, you need specific, documented reasons tied to the 20 best interest factors in F.S. § 61.13(3):
Without evidence, demanding more than 50/50 signals to the mediator that you’re not negotiating in good faith.
Mediation exists to serve the child’s best interests, not to settle scores. Florida courts evaluate 20 specific factors — and one of the most important is each parent’s capacity to facilitate the child’s relationship with the other parent (F.S. § 61.13(3)(a)) [2].
If the mediator notes that you’re focused on punishing the other parent rather than supporting the child’s wellbeing, and the case goes to trial, that observation can hurt you. Judges look for the “friendly parent” — the one most likely to support the child’s relationship with both parents.
Mediation is confidential under F.S. § 44.405 — nothing said in mediation can be used at trial [2]. But emotional outbursts still damage the process in real time:
If emotions rise, ask for a private caucus (separate room session) where you can speak privately with the mediator and your attorney. Most mediators expect this and routinely use caucuses to manage difficult conversations.
Mediation is negotiation. Coming in with absolute positions and refusing to move on any point is the fastest way to impasse. When mediation fails, the case goes to trial — which costs 10-50x more and puts all decisions in a judge’s hands [3].
Effective mediation strategy requires identifying your priorities vs. preferences:
Give ground on flexible items to protect your non-negotiables. The mediator will note whether you’re a reasonable negotiator.
Mediation isn’t a trial, but documentation strengthens your position. Bring:
Documentation turns “I’m the more involved parent” from an opinion into a verifiable fact.
Speaking negatively about the other parent in mediation — or worse, to your children — backfires badly. Florida courts consider parental alienation when evaluating the 20 best interest factors, and a pattern of badmouthing can result in reduced time-sharing or even a change of majority time-sharing [2].
In mediation, frame concerns objectively:
Specific, factual statements are more persuasive than emotional characterizations.
A mediated agreement, once approved by the court, becomes a binding court order. Agreeing to a schedule you can’t realistically maintain — because of your work schedule, commute, or other commitments — sets you up for non-compliance and contempt.
Before agreeing, honestly evaluate:
While you’re not required to have an attorney at mediation, going without one is risky — especially in custody cases involving the 50/50 presumption, complex schedules, or relocation. An experienced family law attorney:
Everything said in mediation is confidential and inadmissible at trial under F.S. § 44.405 [2]. This means:
Use this to your advantage. Confidentiality means you can float proposals, test the other side’s flexibility, and negotiate freely. Too many parents hold back in mediation out of fear — don’t make that mistake.
Yes. Under F.S. § 61.183, mediation is required for all contested family law issues, including time-sharing and parental responsibility. You must attempt mediation before the court will schedule a trial, unless there’s a documented history of domestic violence.
Private mediation typically costs $150-$350 per hour, with most custody mediations taking 4-8 hours ($1,000-$8,000 total). Some circuits offer court-connected mediation at reduced rates. If the case goes to trial instead, expect to spend $15,000-$50,000+ in attorney fees and court costs.
No. A mediator is a neutral facilitator, not a decision-maker. The mediator cannot impose a settlement, give legal advice to either party, or make recommendations to the judge. Both parents must voluntarily agree to any mediated settlement. If no agreement is reached, the case proceeds to trial where the judge decides.
If mediation reaches impasse (no agreement), the mediator files an impasse report with the court. The case then proceeds to trial, where a judge will hear evidence and impose a parenting plan. The mediator cannot report what was said or offered — only that no agreement was reached. Trial typically adds 6-12 months and significantly higher costs.
Generally, no. Mediation is typically limited to the parents, their attorneys, and the mediator. Bringing a new partner can inflame tensions and distract from the child’s interests. However, if your new partner is a stepparent who will be involved in day-to-day parenting, discuss with your attorney whether their input is relevant to the parenting plan.
Sources:
[1] Florida Courts, Alternative Dispute Resolution Statistics FY 2024-25. flcourts.gov
[2] Florida Legislature, F.S. § 61.13, § 61.183, § 44.405 (2025). leg.state.fl.us
[3] American Bar Association, Dispute Resolution Section — Family Mediation Resources. americanbar.org
[4] Florida Legislature, Ch. 2023-301 — Family Law Reform (50/50 Time-Sharing Presumption). laws.flrules.org
[5] Florida Courts, Statistical Reference Guide FY 2023-24, Chapter 5: Family Court. flcourts.gov
✓Written by
Family Law Attorney & Partner, Sacks & Sacks
